Teaching the Meaning of Liberty

Baltimore Sanitary Fair“We all declare for liberty,” Abraham Lincoln remarked in 1864, “but in using the same word we do not all mean the same thing.” That word gets thrown around a lot when we talk about, and especially when we commemorate, the early American republic. Since I started my job two years ago, I’ve been teaching a course on “the meaning of liberty” from Revolution to Civil War. In this post I want to reflect on the process of designing, teaching, and redesigning that course—a process of thinking through American “liberty” with my twenty-first century British students in mind.

The truth is, I find it hard even to begin thinking collectively about freedom. Our starting point is unfreedom. It was the same for Thomas Jefferson. His Declaration of Independence gives meaning to liberty by listing its violations. When we read David Walker, William Lloyd Garrison, Frederick Douglass, and Harriet Jacobs in my class, we try to glimpse freedom by looking deep into its absence. But it’s too easy for students to assume that because slavery has been abolished in America, the problem of liberty has already been solved. Spend too long pondering slavery, and just about anything else starts to look like liberty.

There were critics of abolitionists who tried to raise the same problem. In my class, we read William West’s series of letters to The Liberator, describing “wages slavery” as a system of dependence, abjection, and poverty which West calls “worse” than chattel slavery. It is wage slavery that can most truly claim to be the “sum of all evils,” West writes, because it is only this variety of slavery that hypocritically appropriates “the name of liberty.” We read West critically, of course. But when I ask my students if they ever felt like their boss was a tyrant, that’s when they begin to understand that freedom is a problem of the present, not just of the nineteenth century.

It’s the curse of such a topic—the meaning of freedom in American history!—to be so deeply bound up with progress. Didn’t things just keep on getting better; sometimes faster, perhaps, and sometimes more slowly, but basically, better? We read Judith Sargent Murray in the second week, then Sarah Grimké in the seventh, the Seneca Falls declaration and Lucretia Mott in the tenth. One of my students noted how depressing it is to see the same good arguments repeated, periodically, over sixty years of alleged progress. The way we raise and teach our children, the way they imbibe the ideology infused in their surroundings—as those women powerfully described—is an unfreedom none too easily abolished.

But next year I will spend longer with some of the writers that my students this year liked the least—I just marked all their essays, and not one of them wrote on the Transcendentalists. It is one thing to grasp the unfreedom of slaves, women, and even wage workers in nineteenth-century America. Emerson and Thoreau make a different kind of challenge, one that I think cuts even more deeply to the problem of contemporary freedom and unfreedom. Perhaps they write too beautifully for what they’re really saying to be taken seriously, when put alongside the righteous fury of that Frederick Douglass speech or the plain-spoken wisdom of William Manning’s Key of Liberty.

I am no Lincoln scholar, but it seems to me that he was being wry with his Baltimore audience in 1864—for they knew very well that their version of liberty was the true one, and victorious. That speech, less than a page long, has more of freedom in it than the ten thousand word disquisition, “What Is Liberty?” that Albert Blesdoe published in his Southern Review five years later.  Still, I’m glad I made my students read Blesdoe too. They need to know that even after Union victory, there were those who wrote in defence of slavery, and did so under the cover of philosophy and liberty. They need to be able to recognise that kind of thinking when they read it today, and tomorrow, and next year.

2 responses

    • WEEK 1
      [Jefferson et al.], “Declaration of Independence” (1776)
      [Thomas Paine], Common Sense (1776)

      WEEK 2
      Benjamin Rush, Thoughts on the Mode of Education Proper in a Republic (1786)
      Thomas Jefferson, Notes on the State of Virginia (1785)
      Judith Sargent Murray, “On the Equality of the Sexes” (1790)

      WEEK 3
      William Manning, The Key of Liberty (1799)
      Alexander Hamilton and James Madison, Federalist 1 & 10 (1787)
      [Thomas Jefferson], “Kentucky Resolutions” (1798)

      WEEK 4
      David Walker, Appeal to the Coloured Citizens of the World (1829)
      Thomas Skidmore, The Rights of Man to Property! (1829)

      WEEK 5
      William Lloyd Garrison, “Declaration of Sentiments of the American Anti-Slavery Society” (1833)
      John C. Calhoun, “Slavery a Positive Good” (1837)
      Alexis de Tocqueville, Democracy in America (1835)
      John Louis O’Sullivan, “Great Nation of Futurity” (1839)

      WEEK 6 BREAK

      WEEK 7
      Sarah Grimke, Letters on the Equality of the Sexes (1838)
      Ralph Waldo Emerson, “Self-Reliance” (1841)

      WEEK 8
      Frederick Douglass, A Narrative of the Life of Frederick Douglass (1845)
      Harriet Jacobs, Incidents in the Life of a Slave Girl (1861)
      William West, “Wages Slavery and Chattel Slavery” (1846)

      WEEK 9
      Frederick Douglass, “What, To the Slave, Is the Fourth of July?” (1852)
      Salmon Chase, “Address to the Southern and Central Liberty Convention” (1845)
      John Humphrey Noyes, Slavery and Marriage: A Dialogue (1850)

      WEEK 10
      Elizabeth Cady Stanton, “Declaration of Sentiments of the Seneca Convention” (1848)
      Lucretia Mott, “Discourse on Women” (1850)
      Abraham Lincoln, “Young Man’s Lyceum Address” (1838)
      Henry Thoreau, “Civil Disobedience” (1849)

      WEEK 11
      Abraham Lincoln, “Address At a Sanitary Fair” (1864)
      Albert Blesdow, “What Is Liberty?” (1869)


Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: