Making Utopia a Theme in Early American History

Utopia, 1516, frontispieceThis year I’m overhauling my early American survey course. Not only do I need to make it fit the schedule at my new institution, but because I’m planning to be teaching here for quite a while, I also want to build a course that carries my own signature, and where I can work out some of my own questions and ideas. Survey courses that I’ve taught before—like the one designed by Sarah Pearsall for Oxford Brookes University—have been themed around the violence of empire and slavery. Obviously, those continue to be both central concerns in teaching and the foci of cutting-edge scholarship. But in my search for something different, and for something that might capture the imaginations of my first-year students, I’ve chosen a different path: utopia.

What I mean by that is the drive to imagine and create new forms of society—often radically discontinuous from those they sprung from, whether geographically separated or emerging from revolutionary transformation. As in Thomas More’s original Utopia of 1516, there was both a Christian and a secular humanist dimension to this drive. The context in which More wrote his book was not far removed from the one in which English colonialism began in the New World. It would be quite a stretch to say that every colonist was a utopian, or any colony a utopia. But that’s not the point.

I want my course to explore the range of motivations that lay behind the enormous, expensive, and dangerous efforts to begin, perpetuate, and transform European empires in North America, from the perspective of participants as well as empires themselves. As much as poverty, greed, fear, and family ties made up a good deal of that collective motivation, I don’t think those factors should obscure the intellectual and emotional experience of settlers, migrants, or their successors. The same can be said for enslaved people and their successors, and the Native people whose worlds were also transformed. One way or another, they all participated in utopian projects, however misguided and unjust, however failed and catastrophic.

I’m aware of the big, flashing “Warning!” signs that might be going off in readers’ heads right now. After all, it’s taken generations of work by historians, teachers, and activists to move us on from exceptionalist patriotic narratives, and to put the horrors of slavery and empire at the centre of the North American story. Is it really sane to imagine reframing that story in terms of utopian dreams? Isn’t it downright offensive? Well, I’m working through these ideas, and I hope you’ll pull me up if you think I’ve gone off the deep end.

Utopia is always an inherently doomed project, grappling with the quintessentially human disconnection between imagination and reality. The utopian impulse is also a critical one, as Fredric Jameson has pointed out. Its visions are born out of frustration and discontent, and they hold within themselves an implicit critique of actually existing conditions. The clearest example of that, at least in my plan for the survey, is the utopian, millenarian dimension of slave rebellions down the centuries. But it’s also true of the more explicitly utopian communities established throughout the history of Euro-American settlement—and, one might also say, of the United States itself. These critiques haven’t always been correct, of course, but understanding them is a way to grasp both past conditions and how people understood them.

So, I’ll report back on how all this goes with students in the room. I don’t intend to explicitly signpost my theme. Rather, I’m allowing it to guide me as I write my lectures and approach the contours of the survey as a whole. By the end of the term, however, I hope students will have caught on. And given how much we’ll also have learned about the violence and barbarity of early America, I hope they will start to see the tensions that make utopia a fruitful avenue of narrative investigation.

3 comments on “Making Utopia a Theme in Early American History

  1. Thanks for this Tom!
    Utopia as an organizing theme is something I’ve spent time thinking about as well, although more in the context of my dissertation than teaching. One thing I’ve tried to play with as a means to capture both the utopianism and the violence of early North America is to think about the ways in which particular visions of political economy/right social order/etc implicitly or explicitly require violence and exclusion to be enacted. To use a pretty obvious example, a nation of yeoman farmers is intolerant of other ways of living on the land and has a hard time reconciling itself to the notion of independent Native nations, but I think this principle can be extended to all manner of utopian visions—European and non. Even explicitly integrationist notions (like, arguably, things like the 1763 Royal Proclamation which imagines an empire that includes Native people) tend to require integration or coexistence along very particular lines which often have violence and oppression at their heart, or at the very least put control in particular hands and not others.

  2. Marie McDaniel says:

    I’ve been using utopia as a theme in the survey for about 6 years. I like it, although I prefer case studies to overall narrative for the survey. I think it works really well. Students understand the idea of wanting to start over, to create something new- they are college freshmen after all. And struggling with the idea that one person’s utopia sometimes leads to another person’s destruction is very thought-provoking.

  3. […] it as shorthand to describe any number of idealistic but ill-conceived expeditions and ministries, utopias and schemes. Cervantes’ tide of heroes and villains seeped into private correspondence and spinoff […]


Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s